Skip to Main Content
Vassar

Today's hours:

See all library hours »

  • Ask a Librarian
  • FAQ

SOCI 151: Introductory Sociology

Prof. Light Carruyo, Spring 2024

Key Questions for Strategic Reading

Not all articles will use these exact subheadings, however these questions can still be used to focus your reading.

Article Section Key Questions
Abstract
  • What is the objective of the study?
  • What results from the study are presented in the abstract?
Introduction
  • What issues does the author seem to be concerned about?
  • What is the gap in previous research that the authors are addressing with this study?
Methods
  • How does the author test their hypothesis?
  • What data was collected? How is it used?
Results
  • What were the major findings of the article?
  • Are the main findings expected?
Discussion
  • Does the article meet its objectives?
  • Does the author address the problems or limitations of their research methods?
  • What does the author suggest as future research?

Evaluating Sources: ACT UP

Graphic of ACT UP method in acrostic format. ACT UP letters are larger and stylized to look like magazine cutouts. Text reads: Author - who wrote this? what do you know about the author? Are they qualified to speak on this topic? What are the credentials? Can you Google the author? Find a LinkedIn page? Anything else they wrote? Currency - how current is this research? When was it written? When was it published? Does this resource fit into the currency of your topic? Truth - how true/accurate is this information? Does the language of the source contain words to evoke an emotional response? Are there typos and spelling mistakes? Can you verify any of the claims in other sources? Unbias - is the information presented to sway the audience to a particular point of view? Resources should be impartial unless otherwise stated. Remember, bias is not always a bad thing as long as the source is explicit about their agenda. What about confirmation bias? Does this affect the way you search and choose resources? Privilege - check the privilege of the author(s). Why is this research present in the database? Are they the only folks that might write or publish on this topic? Who is missing in this conversation? Critically evaluate the subject terms associated with each resource you found. How are they described? What are the inherent biases of the publishing industry and library classification systems?

(Image text from Dawn Stahura's “ACT UP: Evaluating Sources”) 

If an author is privileged or biased in some way, that should not automatically disqualify a source from being used. However, it’s important to keep it in mind as you work on building your list of sources. This guide to inclusive citation has some helpful tips and information for doing this. 

How to Use a Source

The BEAM model provides a framework for identifying how you might use a source in your own research. 

BEAM model details: Background to present information and establish facts; Exhibit to explicate, interpret, analyze; Argument to affirm, dispute, refine, extend; and Method to provide a critical lens, key terms, theory, style, perspective and discourse